The best cold email in the world does nothing in a spam folder. Whether you land in the inbox depends far more on your set-up, your volume and your list than on your words. This is the playbook we follow for every pilot, written so you can follow it yourself.
Never send cold email from your main domain
Inbox providers judge senders largely by domain. If cold email to strangers draws spam complaints, the reputation of that domain drops, and then your quotes, invoices and replies to real customers start landing in spam too.
So send cold email from a separate domain that looks like yours: for ortizpainting.com, something like getortizpainting.com or ortizpainting.co. Point its website to your real site, so anyone who checks finds you. A bad week on the sending domain then never touches your main one.
The four DNS records
| Record | What it does | Example |
|---|---|---|
| SPF | Lists the servers allowed to send for the domain | v=spf1 include:_spf.google.com ~all (Google Workspace) |
| DKIM | Signs each email so it can be checked as really yours | A key your email provider gives you, added as a TXT or CNAME record |
| DMARC | Tells inboxes what to do when checks fail, and sends you reports | v=DMARC1; p=none; rua=mailto:you@yourdomain |
| MX | Where replies are delivered | The MX records from Google Workspace or Microsoft 365 |
Check all four in seconds with our free domain check. Start DMARC at p=none, read the reports for a few weeks, then move to p=quarantine.
Gmail and Yahoo's sender rules
Since February 2024, Gmail and Yahoo have required every sender to authenticate their mail and keep spam complaints low. In short, from Google's published guidelines:
- Every sender: SPF or DKIM, valid forward and reverse DNS, TLS, and a spam complaint rate under 0.3% (Google advises staying under 0.1%).
- Bulk senders (around 5,000 or more messages a day to Gmail): SPF and DKIM and DMARC, the From domain aligned with them, and one-click unsubscribe on marketing mail.
Microsoft has announced similar requirements for high-volume senders to Outlook.com addresses. A trade firm's cold email is far below 5,000 a day, but meet the bulk rules anyway. They are what a careful sender looks like.
Warm up every new inbox
A brand-new inbox that sends 50 cold emails on day one looks exactly like a spammer. Warm it up over 14-21 days first:
- Week 1: a handful of real emails a day, to people who will reply: suppliers, colleagues, your own other addresses.
- Week 2: more of the same, a little more volume each day.
- Week 3: the first cold emails, about 10 a day, rising slowly towards your target.
Warm-up services that trade emails between inboxes can help, but they are no substitute for real conversations and a clean list.
Keep the volume low and steady
- Under 30 cold emails per inbox a day. More reach means more inboxes, not more per inbox. Size it with the inbox calculator.
- Space the sends out. A few minutes apart over the working day, never a burst of 30 in a minute.
- Send in business hours, in the recipient's time zone, on weekdays.
- Keep it steady. Sudden jumps in volume are a warning sign to providers.
A clean list matters more than anything
Bounces tell inbox providers you are guessing at addresses. Keep the bounce rate under 2%:
- Verify every address before it goes into a sequence.
- Prefer named work addresses over info@ or office@.
- Be careful with catch-all domains: they accept everything, so a bad address only shows up later.
- Remove every hard bounce at once, and never send to it again.
Write plain emails
- Plain text, short, written like a person. 50-125 words.
- No attachments. No images. No link in the first email, or one at most.
- Consider turning off open tracking: it adds a hidden image and rewrites links, and both can count against you.
- A personal first line about their building or company.
- No spammy phrases. Run every email through our spam check.
Make opting out easier than the spam button
Someone who cannot find a way out presses "Report spam", and each complaint hurts. Put a plain line at the bottom: "Not the right person? Reply no thanks and I won't email again." Then honour it at once and keep a suppression list. The footer also needs your postal address under CAN-SPAM; the footer maker writes it for you.
Warning signs, and what to do
| Sign | Likely cause | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Bounces above 2% | Old or guessed addresses | Pause, re-verify the list, remove bad rows |
| Bounces that say blocked or rejected | The domain or inbox reputation has dropped | Pause that inbox for a week, cut volume, check DNS |
| Replies fall to zero overnight | Mail moved to spam | Send test emails to a few addresses of your own on Gmail and Outlook and see where they land |
| Spam complaints | Wrong people, or no easy opt-out | Tighten the targeting, make the opt-out plainer |
Checklist
- A separate sending domain, redirecting to your site.
- SPF, DKIM, DMARC and MX all green.
- 14-21 days of warm-up for every new inbox.
- Under 30 cold emails per inbox a day, spaced out.
- A verified list, bounces under 2%.
- Plain emails, no attachments, no link in the first one.
- A clear opt-out and your postal address in every email.